Retirement marks an important change in life, and with it comes the weighty responsibility of managing your finances in a new way. This isn't merely a logistical challenge; how you approach the inevitable volatility of markets is a reflection of your inner philosophy. The Stoics, with their emphasis on discipline and controlling emotion, offer a timeless framework for this. The goal isn't to eliminate risk—an impossible feat—but to master your response to it.
Here are some guiding principles, inspired by Stoic thought, to consider when defining your risk tolerance.
The Dichotomy of Control: Your Actions vs. Market Outcomes
The core of Stoicism lies in distinguishing what we can control from what we cannot. In investing, you cannot control the market's daily gyrations, a recession, or the actions of other investors. These are externals, akin to the weather or the tides.
What you can control are your actions and your mindset. You can control your spending habits, your savings rate, and the discipline with which you execute a well-considered plan. You can control your reaction to bad news, choosing reason over panic. Your risk tolerance, therefore, is not a measure of the market’s behavior, but a measure of your own inner resolve. It is the capacity to remain calm and steadfast in the face of what is beyond your command.
The Premeditation of Adversity: Preparing for the Worst
Stoic philosophy encourages us to contemplate potential misfortune not to dwell in fear, but to prepare ourselves for its reality. In financial planning, this means asking uncomfortable but necessary questions:
- What if a significant market downturn occurs at the start of my retirement?
- What if my essential expenses are higher than I anticipated?
- What if I face an unexpected medical or family expense?
By meditating on these possibilities, you can structure your portfolio with an understanding of what is necessary for your well-being. This isn't about being pessimistic; it's about being prepared. This contemplation helps you define your capacity for risk—the objective, mathematical boundary of how much loss your portfolio can absorb without jeopardizing your ability to meet your fundamental needs and goals.
Living in Accord with Nature: Aligning Your Finances with Your Values
A Stoic lives a life of virtue, aligning their actions with their true values. When it comes to your finances, this means asking:
- What is the purpose of this wealth? Is it to chase an ever-growing number, or is it to secure a life of peace and freedom from worry?
- What is "enough"? The Stoics understood that true wealth is not an abundance of possessions, but a lack of desire.
Your retirement plan should reflect this. If your primary goal is to provide for your needs and live a life of tranquility, then a portfolio built to withstand market turbulence may be more virtuous than one designed for aggressive growth at the cost of your peace of mind. The right level of risk is the one that supports your pursuit of a well-lived life, free from fear or greed.
Finding your risk tolerance is not an external search for an optimal number. It is an internal journey of self-knowledge and discipline. It is about understanding what is truly important, preparing for the unpredictable, and finding peace in the certainty that you are in control of your choices, if not the outcomes.
Disclaimer: This blogpost provides general information about estate and financial planning and is not intended as legal or financial advice. It’s essential to consult with a qualified estate planning attorney and financial advisor to discuss your specific needs and create a plan that’s right for you.